One: a genuine alternative degree the student would actually take
This is the strategy most students think they are choosing and most are not. The test is a single question, and it is worth asking it out loud in a one-to-one: if the four medicine offers do not come, and this is the only offer on the table next August, will you go? If the answer is anything other than a clear yes, the choice is decoration and the student has effectively applied to four courses with an empty fifth slot.
Where this strategy earns its place is with a student who is genuinely interested in the science rather than only in the job. A subject such as biomedical science, physiology, pharmacology or another life science is a degree they would enjoy for its own sake, and it keeps a documented route back open: graduate entry medicine is a real, structured pathway with its own entry requirements and its own admissions test in many cases, not a rumour. The important word is documented. A student should be able to name the graduate entry courses that accept their proposed degree and say what those courses ask for, before they make the choice, not after a rejection.
Two cautions a careers lead should raise early, because a student will not find them on a prospectus. Graduate entry medicine is a small and competitive system in its own right, so it is a route and not a guarantee; treat it as a second application rather than an escalator. And internal transfer from a science degree into medicine at the same university is rare and, at most universities, does not exist at all. If a student is relying on a transfer, the school should ask them to point at the university's own published policy. Usually there is nothing to point at.
The question to ask in a one-to-one
If this is your only offer next August, will you take it? Anything other than a clear yes means the fifth choice needs rethinking while there is still time to research an alternative properly.
Where the detail lives
- Graduate entry medicine: the overview
What the graduate entry route actually is, who it is open to and what it asks for. Read this before a student commits to a science degree as their route back.
- The GAMSAT, explained
Several graduate entry courses require a separate admissions test. Worth a student knowing that in Year 13, not in their final undergraduate year.
- Deciding on medicine: a step by step guide
For the student who is not yet certain. A fifth choice conversation is often really a first choice conversation in disguise.
- Graduate entry dentistry
The same principle on the dentistry side, for a student whose four were dental courses.





